By Lena LaJoy
The University of Maryland’s Teaching and Learning Transformation Center held the workshop “Alternative Grading Strategies” on Tuesday in the Edward St. John Learning and Teaching Center. This event allowed for instructors to share their experiences with alternative grading and learn about new strategies to help students succeed.
Emily Berman, an educational development specialist with TLTC, hosted the workshop. Berman had teachers reflect their views on grading, shared four examples of how teachers can implement alternative grading practices and provided teachers time to speak about their experience while asking questions about how to proceed.
The four methods Berman said are typically implemented in the classroom as alternative grading methods are: ungrading, labor-based grading, specification grading and standards-based grading.
Berman explained that ungrading is when grades themselves are de-emphasized and teachers focus instead on feedback or self-reflection.
Labor-based grading focuses on giving students credit for finishing work properly and fully rather than focusing on what is right or wrong, while specification grading involves teachers set up specific details for students to see how well and how much they need to do to receive certain grades.
Standards-based grading uses a specific rubric — the EMRN rubric — to assess students based on specific skills.
Berman said she first became interested in alternative grading strategies when she read the book “Grading for Equity” by Joe Feldman while teaching AP Physics.
“It sort of started me on this path of just thinking about, ‘what do our grades really communicate? Are they equitable? Is it something that students can actually use to learn, or is it something that I’m giving and they’re receiving and sort of trying to fix that power imbalance?’” Berman said.
Berman has been at the UMD for three years. She said she has used her skills to try to help teachers make learning more enjoyable.
Similar workshops are held once a semester, according to Berman. Besides workshops, TLTC mainly focuses on departmental and personalized work for teachers.
Patrick Nelson, an adjunct lecturer in the professional writing department, said he has had a positive experience so far with ungrading because it helps him give better feedback and takes some weight off his shoulders.
“With writing, because it’s so subjective, it gives me an opportunity to give better feedback and to dig into not just how you are constructing your sentences and paragraphs, but the analytical part,” Nelson said.
Nelson said one struggle he has faced with ungrading is that the graded assignments he does have come later in the semester, and he sometimes struggles to decide what should be graded and what should not.
Nelson said UMD is doing great at providing opportunities for teachers to learn more about alternative grading strategies and implement those changes.
“I’m lucky I have a department, and a particular program, that is giving us the space to learn about it and implement it if we want,” Nelson said.
Ginny Hutcheson, a learning experience designer, said alternative grading strategies can potentially decrease how often students use artificial intelligence.
Because students have less pressure to be right under alternative grading, teachers focus on them being able to fully understand and complete their assignments.
“Some alternative grading strategies can place the emphasis more on the learning process rather than the outcome, which can reduce that incentive to use AI,” Hutcheson said.
Hutcheson said the university provides many paths for teachers to implement alternative grading strategies. The main guideline the university provides is that teachers still need to give students a grade at the end of the semester.
“There’s kind of a national push around this in higher ed, through some grants and things,” Hutcheson said.
TLTC provides many opportunities for students to learn more about alternative grading strategies and improve their courses throughout their time at UMD.
“I want to emphasize that our whole office is here to support learning on campus,” Berman said. “If people have ideas or want to gather more to talk about this, please reach out to our team because we’d love to continue the conversation.”
Featured Image: University of Maryland professors discuss alternative grading strategies in the Edward St. John Learning and Teaching Center on Nov. 10, 2026. Photo by Audrey Bengtson.
